Cookies and data use

We use cookies to personalise content, to provide social media features and to analyse our traffic. With your consent we share some information about your use of our site with our analytics partner who may combine it with other information that you have provided to them or that they have collected from your use of their services. You consent to use some cookies if you continue to use this website.

Our own in-house analytics must remain turned on for the site to function; information collected by this service is never shared. You can choose to opt out of Google services by clicking on the optional tick below. If you choose to create an account, we will store the information you provide on our servers and a copy of the information on your computer so that you are able to use the website properly.

Your web browser has sent a "Do Not Track" request, in order to honour this Google Analytics has been automatically disabled for your visit. You can change your settings data use settings below. Click "Okay" when you're finished.

Required:  ✔ Essentials   ✔ Respecting Do Not Track  
Optional:  Google services

Blog post image cap

Problematising Halloween

Published about 2 years ago by Ann Baker

A Halloween Problem

Ann worked with Year 3 students in the lead up to Halloween. She told the class that she wanted to make 12 trick or treat bags for a Halloween party but didn’t know what to put in them. The students were quick to identify the quintessential ingredients for the bags. The problem that emerged is shown below along with a few student samples that demonstrate a wide range of strategies.

12 bags

Each bag will have: 6 sour worms 2 sets of vampire teeth 5 bubble gums 4 jelly snakes 10 mini- marshmallows 3 lolly pops 13 little chocolates

How many of each type of sweets will that be? How many sweets will that be to fill the bags altogether?

Student Work

This problem had just the right level of difficulty for the class who engaged readily and persisted with the problem solving process. As is usual with these problems, there was a broad range of approaches allowing students multiple entry points into the problem.

Not all students answered all parts of the problem as can be seen in work sample 1. This student demonstrated that he had interpreted the problem as a multiplicative situation and linked the multiplications to two different representational forms for multiplication. He is developing a firm foundation for connecting these strategies to the more formal strategies of multiplication. You can also see that he was applying fix up strategies as he worked. Halloween1-1

Work sample 2 shows the flexible use of known multiplication facts. She has used the distributive property to split 12 into 10 and 2 because she ‘knows her 10s and knows how to double’. The realism of the problem connected to her and is manifested by her idea of presenting each type of sweet in its own box so that it could be used as a shopping list. halloween1-2

The third sample shows a different strategy, though not fully correct or complete (she was working on her fix up strategy when time eluded her), she focused on the second question rather than the individual parts. She worked out 43 sweets in each bag and began to carry out a repeated addition with chunking. As she began chunking her answers, place value problems became visible. As formative assessment these types of problematised situations make visible gaps and error patterns that might otherwise be over looked. halloween1-3

The following work sample shows how one student checked the reasonableness of his answers, giving ticks before moving onto the second question, how many altogether. As a work sample that shows the working out and steps involved this one really makes the student’s thinking visible. halloween1-4

And last, the next sample shows counting in 2s, 3s and 5s as well as the use of tallies, with the totals being rearranged to make good use of friendly numbers. halloween1-5

Over all the samples give a snap shot of the range of strategies and levels of development that can be seen in any class. Thank you to the class and the teachers involved. The students were AWESOME.

Like to know more about Problematised Situations? Join us here:

Join Natural Maths

Our problem solving products are here.

Share this post